If you have been diving open circuit for years and the idea of switching to a closed-circuit rebreather has crossed your mind, you have probably wondered how the two actually compare. Open-circuit scuba and CCR diving both get you underwater, but they do it in fundamentally different ways, and those differences affect everything from your gas consumption to the marine life you encounter.
This is not a case of one being universally better than the other. Open circuit is proven, simple, and perfectly suitable for many types of diving. But as your goals evolve, understanding where CCR excels helps you make an informed decision. Here is an honest, side-by-side comparison.
How the Two Systems Work
Open Circuit: Breathe and Vent
Open-circuit scuba is straightforward. You breathe compressed gas from a cylinder through a regulator, and every exhalation is released into the water as bubbles. The system is mechanically simple: first stage reduces tank pressure, second stage delivers gas on demand, and everything you exhale is gone. Your dive time is limited by how much gas is in your tank and how fast you consume it.
Closed-Circuit Rebreather: Recycle and Replenish
A CCR like the AP Diving Inspiration works on a closed loop. When you exhale, the gas does not escape into the water. Instead it travels through a scrubber canister filled with Sofnolime, which chemically removes the carbon dioxide your body produces. Two independent oxygen controllers then monitor the partial pressure of oxygen (ppO2) in the loop and add just enough O2 to maintain your chosen setpoint. The scrubbed, re-oxygenated gas returns to you for the next breath. You are recycling the same volume of gas, only replacing what your body actually metabolizes.
The Comparison
| Factor | Open Circuit | CCR (AP Diving Inspiration) |
| Gas Efficiency | Uses entire cylinder contents; ~96% of O2 vented as waste | Recycles exhaled gas; only replaces metabolized O2. Dramatically lower consumption |
| Bottom Time | 45-60 min typical on a single tank at recreational depths | 2-3 hours of multilevel no-stop diving on the same gas supply |
| Noise | Exhale bubbles create noise and visual disturbance | Silent operation; no exhaust bubbles during normal diving |
| Gas Mix Optimization | Fixed mix (e.g., nitrox 32) regardless of depth | Constant optimal ppO2 at every depth, automatically adjusted by dual controllers |
| Decompression | Fixed mix means less efficient off-gassing | Optimal ppO2 at all depths reduces decompression obligations |
| Breathing Gas Temperature | Cold, dry gas from cylinder | Warm, humid gas heated by exothermic scrubber reaction |
| Buoyancy | Buoyancy shifts as tank empties (lighter at end of dive) | Stable buoyancy; loop volume stays constant regardless of gas consumption |
| Equipment Complexity | Mechanically simple; fewer components | More components; dual controllers, scrubber, oxygen cells, electronics |
| Pre-Dive Preparation | Visual inspection, regulator check, buddy check (5-10 min) | Full checklist: positive/negative pressure tests, cell checks, scrubber packing, electronics calibration (15-25 min) |
| Training Required | Open Water certification (3-5 days) | OW + Advanced OW prerequisite, then CCR-specific course (5-7 days intensive) |
| Maintenance | Annual regulator service, visual cylinder inspection | Pre/post-dive care, periodic O2 cell replacement, scrubber canister care, annual service by certified technician |
| Safety Redundancy | Relies on single gas delivery path (plus buddy as backup) | AP Diving: dual independent O2 controllers (C1/C2), dual battery system, fiber optic HUD, plus open-circuit bailout |
| Initial Cost | Lower entry point | Higher upfront investment; lower per-dive cost over time |
Where Open Circuit Still Makes Sense
Open-circuit diving is not going anywhere. For short recreational dives on a holiday, for divers who dive a handful of times per year, or for situations where simplicity and minimal pre-dive preparation are priorities, OC remains practical and reliable. It also requires less training and lower initial investment, making it the natural starting point for every diver.
Many CCR divers still keep open-circuit gear in their kit. There are days when a quick shore dive on a single tank is exactly what you want, and there is nothing wrong with that.
Where CCR Changes the Game
The advantages of CCR compound the more you dive and the more demanding your diving becomes. If you regularly dive three or more times per week, the gas savings alone become significant. If you do technical diving, the decompression advantages are substantial. If underwater photography is your focus, silent diving is transformative.
CCR also excels on multi-day dive trips. Instead of burning through tank fills, you can do three long dives per day on modest amounts of oxygen and diluent. The reduced surface intervals and extended bottom times mean you see and experience more on every trip.
The AP Diving Difference
Not all rebreathers approach safety the same way. The AP Diving Inspiration is the only recreational CCR with dual independent oxygen controllers as standard. Controller C1 manages your ppO2 while C2 independently monitors and cross-checks, ready to take over instantly if anything interrupts C1. Both controllers are permanently encapsulated in the scrubber lid for water and vibration protection. Each draws from an intelligent dual-battery system, eliminating single-point-of-failure risk.
Connected to each controller is a fiber optic heads-up display using flexible polyethylene fiber optic cables, showing green for normal and red for attention at a glance, with no electronics to waterproof at the display end. This means critical status information is always in your field of vision without checking a wrist unit.
The Inspiration range also offers a choice of front-mounted Over The Shoulder (OTS) counterlungs, which provide the lowest work of breathing of any rebreather counterlung available, or rear-mounted Back Mounted Counterlungs (BMCL) for a streamlined, clutter-free chest area that technical divers prefer.
Who Should Consider Making the Switch
You should seriously consider CCR if you are an experienced open-circuit diver who wants more from your diving, whether that means longer bottom times, closer wildlife encounters, or a path into technical diving with optimized decompression. The AP Diving Inspiration range comes in three chassis sizes (XPD, EVP, and EVO) and every unit can be configured from recreational to full technical specification through software key upgrades, so the unit grows with your ambitions.
As the exclusive distributor of AP Diving products in the Americas, Silent Diving supports divers through every stage of the transition, from finding a training center to configuring the right unit for your diving goals.
Learn about the Inspiration range | Find a dealer near you | Talk to us
Need help applying this to your own CCR setup?
Talk with Silent Diving before your next dive.
Get practical guidance on AP Diving products, rebreather service, parts, training, and planning support from the Silent Diving team.